I have a similar problem here in NH and my TX antenna is a modified oldie CC 6el Boomer and now 8 el on a 35' boom. YO says the gain is 13.6dBi and the F/R is in excess of 40dB from 50.0 to 50.4 as I designed it to get rid of a lot of noise sources over the full 180 degree rear when working DX toward EU and AF.
On AM I run a Clegg Zeus at about 120W out and could raise a QSO most any evening when beaming from RI and up around to the Albany area on an otherwise completely dead frequency. It is pretty sharp and does not make for spread out roundtables.
For that I have a pair of 2 el horizontal collinear elements (2 half waves insulated and fed in the center, about 9' long) skewed about 45 degrees or so and stacked a half wave. Feed between them is OWL and a coax balun to 75 Ohm coax. A bit of gain, close to omni directional, and do the job. Lots of info in old hand
A turnstile is circular polarized so there is a built in 3dB loss to V or H antennas and maximum radiation is straight up. It would be better to feed them in phase and tune out the reactance.
Many also use an 80M dipole with decent results, Ive worked 10W stations over 50 miles with one, and Europeans and West Coast NA when the band is open. That big yagi and a hilltop is a good equalizer
Carl