If that's their motivation, and they're good at it, I have no problem with that. New hams have to start somewhere. If the interest continues and grows, that's even better. Not all new hams come into the fold with hot soldering irons in their hands or wire dangling from their pockets. Not everyone needs or wants high technical aspirations in the amateur radio hobby.
Pete, I agree with you entirely. I have no grumble with those who are intially motivated by emcomms or public service to come into our hobby, and who then participate in it. I'm very heavily involved with emcomms myself, to the point of being a member of our county Emergency Management team and also on the EM team at the university I work at. My gripe is with those who get their license and then wait, never making a contact, until somebody tells them they're needed. With no on-air experience, they won't be much help because they simply won't know how to communicate within the structured framework of an emergency net.
And there ain't much time to train them when half a town has been burned or a city has a swath of destruction from an EF4. All I'm asking is for the one-day-wonders who claim to have gotten involved to provide public service, is to participate in a SET or come out and help with the comms for a bike race. That way they'll at least have a clue of how a net operates and can provide the service they intend to. If they're sincere and really want to help, I don't think that's too much to ask.
ldb
K5WLF